Top Business Insurance Providers for Startups

Starting a business is risky, and insurance is your safety net. From lawsuits to cyber threats, the right insurance can protect your startup from financial disaster. Whether you’re a tech firm, service provider, or brick-and-mortar business, there’s a provider tailored to your needs. Here’s a breakdown of the best options:

• Next Insurance: Best for startups seeking quick, online quotes and customizable policies.
• Embroker: Ideal for startups needing specialized coverage like cyber liability or Directors & Officers (D&O) insurance.
• The Hartford: A reliable choice for businesses with physical locations, offering broad industry expertise.
• Thimble: Perfect for freelancers or project-based startups needing short-term coverage.
• Tivly: A marketplace offering multiple quotes, great for comparing providers.
• Founder Shield: Tailored for venture-backed startups with high-growth potential.
• Vouch: Focused on tech startups, offering solutions for unique risks like data breaches.
• CoverWallet: Simple, budget-friendly insurance for early-stage businesses.

Each provider has its strengths. For fast, digital solutions, Next Insurance and Thimble stand out. If you need specialized coverage, Embroker or Founder Shield might be better. Compare options based on your business type, growth stage, and budget.

Quick Comparison:

Choosing the right insurance depends on your startup’s specific risks and growth plans. Start with essential coverage like general liability and expand as your business grows.

1. Next Insurance

Next Insurance stands out as a leading choice for startups, scoring an impressive 4.8/5 for its overall value, coverage options, and customer service. Established in 2016 and based in San Francisco, California, this digital-first platform has attracted $1.1 billion in investments and recorded over 650,000 website visits in July 2024. These numbers highlight its strong financial foundation and growing appeal among businesses. Here’s a closer look at what it offers startups.

Coverage Options for Startups

Next Insurance provides a wide range of coverage options tailored to the unique challenges startups face. Key offerings include general liability, professional liability (errors & omissions), workers’ compensation, commercial property, and cyber insurance. The platform’s customizable policies allow founders to select coverage based on their industry and specific risks, ensuring they get exactly what they need without overpaying for unnecessary extras.

Transparent Pricing

Next Insurance uses an online pricing system that delivers instant quotes with monthly premium options. Factors like business type, industry, location, employee count, and coverage limits are all considered, giving startups a clear breakdown of how their costs are calculated. This transparency helps founders make informed decisions about their insurance needs.

Streamlined Digital Experience

The platform’s digital-first approach simplifies the entire process. Founders can input their business details, select coverage, and receive quotes – all within minutes. Policies are issued just as quickly. The claims process is equally efficient, with an online system that allows startups to file and track claims. While simple claims are often resolved in just a few days, more complex cases may take a bit longer.

Reliable Customer Support

For startups, having responsive customer support is essential. Next Insurance offers assistance through chat, email, and phone, making it easy for founders to get guidance on coverage options or resolve any issues. Their quick response times ensure that managing insurance needs is as hassle-free as possible.

Features That Grow With Your Business

One of the platform’s standout features is its flexibility. Startups can adjust their coverage online as their business grows, ensuring their policy evolves alongside them without requiring a complete overhaul. That said, coverage for niche industries or complex risks may be limited, and startups needing in-person or highly personalized service might find the online-only model less ideal. Still, for most startups, the convenience and adaptability make it a strong contender.

2. Embroker

Embroker stands out in the startup insurance market by combining the speed of digital tools with the expertise of human guidance. This hybrid approach makes it an excellent choice for startups that need quick solutions without sacrificing personalized support. Every aspect of its offerings is built on this balance of automation and tailored service.

Wide Range of Coverage Options

Embroker provides a variety of insurance products designed to meet the unique needs of growing businesses. These include general liability, professional liability, cyber liability, directors and officers (D&O) insurance, employment practices liability, and workers’ compensation. For tech-driven startups, the cyber liability coverage addresses critical risks like data breaches, ransomware attacks, and regulatory fines. Beyond that, the platform offers specialized options for industry-specific risks, such as:

• Product liability for hardware companies
• Media liability for content creators
• Errors and omissions insurance tailored to service-based businesses

These policies are crafted to handle common startup challenges, from data security issues to legal liabilities.

Budget-Friendly Pricing

Embroker understands the financial constraints of startups and offers a pricing model to match. Founders can choose between annual or monthly payment plans, making it easier to manage cash flow. Standard policies can be quoted instantly online, while more complex needs receive custom quotes. Plus, startups can adjust their coverage – whether it’s changing limits, adding new policies, or updating risk profiles – with clear pricing for every modification. This flexibility, paired with advanced digital tools, ensures startups get exactly what they need without unnecessary surprises.

Tech-Powered Simplicity

Embroker’s platform leverages automation and expert analysis to assess a startup’s industry, size, and operations. This technology recommends coverage levels that fit the business and simplifies the claims process through a digital portal. Startups can upload documents, track claim statuses, and communicate directly with adjusters – all in one place. This streamlined system speeds up claim resolutions compared to traditional insurance providers.

Personalized Account Support

Every Embroker client is paired with a licensed account manager who provides strategic risk advice. These managers help founders adapt their coverage as the business grows, ensuring compliance with contracts, leases, or regulatory requirements. This hands-on support is invaluable for navigating the complexities of startup insurance.

Built for Growth

As startups expand, Embroker’s platform automatically updates premiums and effective coverage dates to reflect changes like new locations, employees, or business activities. For companies operating across multiple states, Embroker simplifies compliance by coordinating coverage to meet varying state requirements.

3. The Hartford

The Hartford combines its rich history with a modern approach, offering personalized coverage options that cater to traditional businesses. With over 200 years of experience and a reputation for reliability, it’s no wonder more than 500,000 small businesses trust The Hartford to protect their operations. This long-standing legacy makes it one of the most established names in business insurance.

Broad Industry Expertise

The Hartford provides coverage across 20+ industries, including technology, finance, consulting, and manufacturing. This wide-ranging experience is particularly helpful for startups that need customized insurance solutions. Their policy offerings include business owner’s policies (BOP), general liability, commercial property, and professional liability insurance. For startups with physical locations, this all-encompassing approach simplifies insurance management as your business expands.

Quick Quotes, Backed by Expertise

Need pricing fast? The Hartford’s online quote tool delivers estimates in 10 minutes or less. But what sets them apart is their hybrid approach: licensed agents are available to guide you through the details, ensuring your coverage fits your business needs. This combination of speed and expert advice makes the process both efficient and personalized.

Employee-Focused Benefits

The Hartford goes beyond standard insurance with programs like "Nursed Back to Health" and access to its Preferred Medical Provider Network. These offerings are particularly appealing to startups prioritizing employee well-being and recovery.

Coverage and Service Considerations

While The Hartford offers extensive coverage, it’s not available in Alaska, Hawaii, or New Jersey. Additionally, their claims process is a bit slower compared to tech-focused competitors, though their customer service remains highly rated.

Best for Traditional Startups

Startup Savant has awarded The Hartford a 4.6/5 rating for its startup business insurance, highlighting its strength in serving brick-and-mortar businesses. For startups with physical operations or more traditional models, The Hartford’s expertise and flexible coverage options provide dependable protection. Plus, their ability to scale policies as your business grows – paired with strong risk management resources – makes them a trusted choice for founders seeking a proven provider.

4. Thimble

Thimble has carved out a niche as a top choice for solopreneurs and side hustlers, offering coverage options that cater to the unpredictable nature of project-based work. Unlike traditional insurers, Thimble provides hourly, daily, or monthly policies, making it a perfect fit for startups with seasonal or irregular operations.

Flexible Coverage When You Need It

Thimble takes a unique approach by skipping annual contracts and allowing businesses to get coverage only when needed. Their offerings include general liability, professional liability, and equipment insurance – key protections for freelancers, consultants, and creatives. This flexibility is particularly useful for professionals juggling varying schedules or working on diverse projects.

Tailored for Project-Based Work

For startups with fluctuating workloads, Thimble’s short-term policies are a game-changer. You can activate coverage as needed, avoiding the financial burden of year-long premiums. This pay-as-you-go model is especially helpful for businesses in their early stages, where every dollar counts. Plus, managing your policy is easy thanks to Thimble’s digital-first platform.

A Seamless Online Experience

Thimble’s platform is designed for simplicity and speed. You can get quotes, purchase coverage, and even file claims entirely online. This streamlined process is perfect for busy entrepreneurs who need quick, hassle-free solutions.

Affordable and Adjustable Pricing

Thimble’s pricing adapts to your business needs, ensuring you’re not overpaying during slow periods or left without coverage when things get busy. This kind of flexibility makes it a cost-effective choice for small operations looking to manage expenses without sacrificing protection.

Ideal for Creative and Service-Based Startups

Whether you’re a photographer covering weekend events or a consultant handling short-term projects, Thimble’s coverage is designed to keep up with your changing schedule. It’s a reliable option for businesses that thrive on flexibility and need insurance that can adapt as quickly as they do.

5. Tivly

Tivly serves as a marketplace that connects startups with insurance providers, making it easier to find coverage that fits your business needs. Instead of reaching out to insurers one by one, startups can access a variety of carriers and policy options all in one place. Unlike direct insurance providers, Tivly aggregates multiple insurers, offering a streamlined way to compare and select coverage.

Simplified Insurance Shopping

Tivly’s marketplace model allows you to compare quotes from various carriers, often leading to better rates and more tailored coverage. Rather than offering its own policies, Tivly matches you with providers based on your specific industry, risk factors, and insurance needs.

Through the platform, you can access a range of policy types, including general liability, professional liability, business owner’s policies (BOP), commercial property, workers’ compensation, and cyber insurance. This setup gives you the flexibility to create a comprehensive insurance package by combining policies from different providers if necessary.

Competitive Pricing Through Multiple Options

With Tivly, pricing is determined by the insurance providers in their network, not by Tivly itself. This competitive marketplace can help reduce premiums. For example, general liability coverage often starts around $500–$1,000 per year, but your exact costs will depend on factors like your business type, location, and chosen coverage limits.

The ability to quickly compare multiple quotes is particularly useful for startups with unique risk profiles that may not align with standard pricing models from individual insurers.

User-Friendly Digital Platform

Tivly’s online platform simplifies the traditionally time-consuming insurance process. You can request quotes, compare options, and purchase coverage directly through their site. For added convenience, phone and email support are also available to assist you.

Perfect for Non-Traditional Business Models

Startups in niche industries or with unconventional risk profiles stand to benefit the most from Tivly’s approach. Where a single insurer might fall short, Tivly’s network includes specialized carriers that cater to emerging risks and unique operational needs.

For instance, tech startups can find specific cyber liability coverage, while hardware companies might secure specialized product liability insurance – options that traditional insurers might not always provide.

Support for Growing Startups

Tivly also adapts to the evolving needs of growing businesses. Their advisors can help adjust your coverage as your company scales, ensuring your policies grow alongside your operations. This flexibility eliminates the need to switch providers entirely, making it easier to expand or modify your coverage as your business changes.

That said, it’s important to remember that customer service and claims handling will depend on the insurer you select through Tivly’s platform, as they work with multiple carriers.

sbb-itb-ba0a4be

6. Founder Shield

In the competitive world of startup insurance, Founder Shield stands out by offering tailored coverage specifically designed for fast-growing, venture-backed companies.

Coverage Designed for Startups

Founder Shield provides a range of insurance products that are particularly relevant to startups, including general liability, professional liability (E&O), directors and officers (D&O) insurance, cyber liability, employment practices liability, and key person insurance. Their D&O coverage is especially noteworthy, as it meets the unique needs of startups with boards of directors and aligns with investor expectations.

Their reputation within the startup ecosystem is well-established. They’ve worked with 20% of U.S. unicorns, hundreds of Y Combinator-backed startups, and over 150 public companies – highlighting their expertise and trustworthiness in this space.

Flexible Pricing for Growing Businesses

Founder Shield’s pricing is customized based on factors like industry, company size, revenue, and risk profile. While standard rates aren’t published, they focus on delivering competitive, tailored quotes. Their policies are designed to grow with startups, allowing businesses to adjust coverage limits, add new types of insurance, or update endorsements as their needs change.

A Tech-Driven Platform for Modern Founders

Founder Shield’s digital platform gives startups the ability to manage policies, request quotes, and file claims all in one place. This online-first approach simplifies what can often be a cumbersome process, appealing to tech-savvy founders who value efficiency and speed.

Support That Evolves With Your Business

To keep up with the changing risks startups face, Founder Shield assigns dedicated account managers who help adjust coverage as needed. Their responsive customer support and streamlined claims process are designed to handle the fast-paced nature of high-growth businesses.

However, it’s worth noting that Founder Shield’s focus on high-growth, tech-oriented companies may not make them the best fit for traditional brick-and-mortar businesses or those in more conventional industries. That said, their specialized approach aligns perfectly with the evolving needs of startups, complementing other providers in the market.

7. Vouch

Vouch is a digital insurer that zeroes in on the tech sector, offering solutions tailored specifically for technology startups and venture-backed companies. Headquartered in San Francisco and backed by $160 million in funding, Vouch has positioned itself as an insurance provider that truly understands the unique challenges faced by tech firms.

Coverage Designed for Tech Startups

Vouch provides a range of insurance products crafted with technology startups in mind. These include general liability, professional liability (errors & omissions), directors & officers (D&O), employment practices liability, cyber liability, and business property insurance. Their policies address risks unique to the tech world, such as data breaches, intellectual property disputes, and liabilities at the board level.

The D&O and cyber liability coverages stand out as they’re designed to meet the expectations of venture capital investors and regulatory requirements. This makes it easier for startups to secure the insurance they need to satisfy investor due diligence and maintain compliance as they grow.

Fast and Fully Digital Experience

Vouch’s online platform simplifies the insurance process. Startups can receive instant, customized quotes based on their industry, size, and risk profile, with many securing coverage in just minutes. While costs vary depending on the company, small startups might find basic general liability coverage starting at a few hundred dollars annually. More comprehensive packages scale with the company’s growth and insurance needs.

Built for the Startup Ecosystem

Vouch works closely with leading accelerators and venture capital firms, ensuring their services align with the fast-paced needs of high-growth tech companies. This partnership-driven approach allows Vouch’s advisors to better understand the challenges startups face, offering policies that evolve alongside the business. Coverage limits and policy types can be adjusted as companies scale, making it a flexible option for growing enterprises.

Support When It Matters Most

Vouch provides startups with access to insurance advisors who specialize in the unique needs of tech businesses. They also offer online resources for risk management and compliance. Their digital claims process is designed for speed and transparency, enabling startups to file and track claims easily while maintaining clear communication throughout.

Beyond claims, Vouch equips founders with educational tools and proactive risk assessments to help them minimize potential issues before they arise. This forward-thinking approach aligns well with the mindset of many modern startups, which often prioritize prevention and efficiency in all aspects of their operations.

That said, Vouch’s focus on tech companies means it may not be the best fit for startups in more traditional industries or those seeking a conventional insurance provider. However, for tech-driven startups looking for fast, tailored, and digitally enabled support, Vouch is an excellent choice.

8. CoverWallet

CoverWallet stands out for its emphasis on simplicity, offering essential insurance options through a user-friendly digital platform. It provides startups with a straightforward way to secure the coverage they need without unnecessary complexity.

Essential Coverage

CoverWallet focuses on providing the core insurance policies that startups often require. These include:

• General liability insurance, which guards against third-party claims.
• Professional liability coverage, ideal for service-based businesses.
• Workers’ compensation, essential for companies with employees.
• Business owner’s policies (BOPs), which combine multiple coverages into one convenient package.

For early-stage startups, these bundled options are particularly appealing, offering both affordability and ease of management.

Compare and Purchase Online

As a digital marketplace, CoverWallet makes it easy for startups to compare insurance policies from various carriers all in one place. Its platform allows users to quickly evaluate and purchase the policies that fit their needs. This streamlined process saves time and simplifies decision-making, giving startups a clear path to securing essential coverage.

Competitive Standing and Ratings

CoverWallet earns a solid 4.3/5 rating, placing it 8th among startup insurance providers in terms of price, usability, and coverage. While its rating doesn’t quite match competitors like Next Insurance (4.8/5), Embroker (4.7/5), or The Hartford (4.6/5), its strength lies in its straightforward approach to basic insurance needs.

When CoverWallet Works Best

CoverWallet is a great choice for startups looking for simple and accessible insurance solutions. It’s particularly well-suited for:

• Service-based businesses.
• Small teams.
• Self-funded startups needing general liability or workers’ compensation coverage.

However, for startups with more specialized needs – such as venture-backed companies requiring directors and officers (D&O) insurance or tech startups needing cyber liability protection – CoverWallet’s offerings might fall short of expectations.

Pros and Cons Comparison

Here’s a breakdown of the key strengths and weaknesses for each provider, laid out side by side:

When choosing the right provider, consider your startup’s stage and industry focus. Next Insurance stands out with its 4.8/5 rating and impressive FAB score. Embroker offers startup-specific packages but lacks transparency on pricing. Traditional players like The Hartford bring decades of expertise but may be slowed down by agent interactions and limited availability. On the other hand, niche providers like Vouch cater specifically to tech startups.

Funding levels also play a role in shaping these companies’ positions. Next Insurance leads with robust funding and high ratings, while CoverWallet offers simpler, budget-friendly options for those with basic insurance needs.

For early-stage businesses, Thimble or CoverWallet might be a better fit due to their straightforward and flexible offerings. Venture-backed startups, however, may find the specialized coverage from Embroker or Founder Shield more aligned with their needs. The key is to select a provider that balances comprehensive coverage with the specific risks your startup faces.

Conclusion

Choosing the right insurance is a key step in safeguarding your startup’s financial future. Providers like Next Insurance stand out for their strong reputation and investor support, offering startups a mix of comprehensive coverage and easy-to-use online tools. Their success highlights how digital insurers are changing the way startups approach risk management.

It’s not just about ratings, though. Aligning insurance coverage with your startup’s specific needs and growth stage is equally important. For example, early-stage startups should prioritize essential coverage – such as general liability, professional liability, and cyber insurance. Flexible providers like Thimble can cater to these needs. On the other hand, high-growth companies might benefit from scalable options offered by providers like Founder Shield. These tailored solutions reflect the broader shift toward customized, efficient insurance options for startups.

That said, be mindful of potential missteps. Failing to understand policy details or neglecting industry-specific risks can leave critical gaps in coverage. It’s also wise to check the financial stability of insurers through ratings from A.M. Best or Moody’s to ensure reliable claims processing.

The rise of digital insurance providers between 2015 and 2019 has made it easier than ever for startups to access tailored coverage. Whether you go with a digital-first provider like Next Insurance or a more traditional option like The Hartford, the key is to choose a policy that evolves with your business. Making informed decisions about insurance early on can help secure your startup’s long-term success.

FAQs

What types of insurance should a startup prioritize in its early stages?

When deciding on insurance, startups should focus on the specific risks linked to their industry and day-to-day operations. It’s wise to begin by considering potential liabilities. For instance, general liability insurance can help cover accidents or property damage, while professional liability insurance addresses claims related to errors or negligence. Additionally, in today’s digital age, cyber insurance is crucial for protecting against data breaches or cyberattacks.

By prioritizing these areas, your business can guard against common risks and meet any legal or contractual requirements. Customize the coverage to match your startup’s specific needs, ensuring a solid foundation for future success.

What should startups consider when deciding between digital-first and traditional insurance providers?

Startups face an important decision when choosing between digital-first insurance providers and more traditional providers. Each option has its strengths, and the right choice depends on your business’s unique needs and priorities.

Digital-first providers are known for their convenient online tools, faster processes, and often lower costs. This makes them a great option for tech-savvy entrepreneurs or businesses seeking quick and straightforward coverage. If you value efficiency and prefer handling tasks online, this route might align well with your goals.

On the flip side, traditional providers bring personalized service, in-depth consultations, and the reliability that comes with a long-standing reputation. These qualities can be especially appealing to startups with more complex insurance needs or those that benefit from a hands-on approach.

When deciding, consider your startup’s specific requirements, how comfortable you are with online platforms, and the level of guidance you’ll need. For instance, if your business involves high-risk activities or requires specialized policies, a traditional provider might better meet your needs. But if speed and simplicity are your top priorities, a digital-first provider could be the perfect fit.

What’s the difference between getting a business insurance quote online and through traditional insurers?

Getting a business insurance quote online is usually quicker and more convenient than going through traditional insurers. Online platforms let you input basic details about your business and often provide instant quotes. This means you can compare options and even purchase coverage within minutes. Their user-friendly design makes them particularly attractive to startups or small businesses that are short on time.

On the flip side, traditional insurers might take a bit longer since they often involve detailed consultations, whether over the phone or in person. While this process isn’t as fast, it comes with the advantage of personalized advice and tailored coverage, which can be a big plus for businesses with more complex needs. Deciding between the two really comes down to whether you value speed and simplicity or customized guidance more.

Related Blog Posts

• Best Identity Theft Protection Software for Small Businesses
• Business Insurance 101: Essential Policies for Small Businesses
• Emerging Business Trends: Top AI Tools for Startups in 2025